The rapid pace of innovation in medical devices resulted in an unfortunate side effect of increasing medical device recalls in the second half of 2016, according to the July-Dec. 2016Recall Industry Spotlight report released today by Stericycle ExpertSOLUTIONS
The biannual Industry Spotlight, which examines trends in a specific industry, found that medical device recalls heated up quickly as the year progressed, increasing 44 percent from the first half of the year. There were more than 650 medical device recalls in Q3 and Q4 2016, the second highest since at least 2000. More than 180 million products were recalled in total, making it the third highest half year on record since 2000 as well.
“Medical devices are saving lives and improving the quality of life for millions of patients. But as medical technology advances and becomes more complex, these innovations can be more prone to defects, and therefore, more vulnerable to recalls,” said Michael Good, Vice President of Commercial & Client Services, Stericycle ExpertSOLUTIONS.
While the top causes of recalls fluctuated quarter to quarter, a clear pattern emerged: software problems drove the highest number of recalls across the two quarters, with product mislabeling a close second. When examining the number of units affected, quality issues were the leading cause followed by mislabeling, parts problems, and sterility concerns.
“The challenge for medical device companies is that, unlike other industries, there is no single dominant cause of recalls they can focus on improving,” Good added. “Defects and quality problems were all over the map, from misalignment to unbalanced pH levels to improper product transportation.”
The safety of lithium-ion batteries in medical devices was a noteworthy contrast to other industries, the report found. Unlike the battery’s fire hazard problems plaguing consumer products like hoverboards, lithium-ion battery problems have not been as prominent in medical devices.
A likely reason for the disparity is quality control. Consumer electronics are one of the most counterfeited product types in the U.S., making them far more likely to include subpar batteries that put the public at risk. Consumer products also tend to suffer much greater wear and tear. Medical devices have not yet experienced these kinds of threats at the same level. The Industry Spotlight report does, however, caution manufacturers that lithium-ion battery problems could become more commonplace in medical devices as their use increases. Manufacturers would be wise to start making contingency plans for potential recalls since the batteries have specialized transportation, permitting, and destruction requirements.
Q4 2016 Recall Index Key Trends The company also issued its Q4 2016 Recall Index, which reports quarterly on recalls in the food, pharmaceutical, automotive, medical device, and consumer product industries. The Index revealed both positive and negative trends in recalls across industries in the last quarter of 2016.
On the positive side, consumer product recalls fell by 21 percent over the previous quarter, making it the lowest quarter of the year. Automotive-related recalls fared better as well. While recalls increased just slightly (3 percent), the overall number of recalled units dropped a significant 57 percent to nearly 5.3 million – the lowest quarter since Q1 2013.
Recalls in the pharmaceutical and food industries unfortunately trended upward in Q4. Pharmaceutical recalls jumped 28 percent to 83, the highest level since Q3 2014. There was a 12 percent hike in Food and Drug Administration (FDA) food and beverage recalls in Q4, marking the highest quarter since at least Q1 2010.
“We’ve witnessed recall activity fluctuate across industries in recent quarters, and companies never know when their product will be next,” said Good. “It is crucial for businesses of all types and sizes to update their recall plans and prepare in advance to avoid potential consequences with both regulators and customers.”
About the Stericycle Recall Index The Stericycle Recall Index is the only report that aggregates and tracks recall data to help manufacturers and other industry stakeholders navigate the regulatory environment and identify trends. Each quarter Stericycle analyzes data from the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), the FDA and the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA). For more information, please visit www.stericycleexpertsolutions.com/thought-leadership.